“There are two key things that need to happen for SAP to be successful with this,” he said. Joshua has 5 jobs listed on their profile. Spent three years in Europe as an industry analyst and as Correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications. How Team Consistency Impacts Customer Satisfaction: iXerv’s Approach. Josh Greenbaum Analyst EA Consult. Also, please have a look at the perspective of analyst Josh Greenbaum, principal of EAConsult. Having helped pioneer coverage of the enterprise software market in the late 1980s – following now-defunct companies like D&B and Cullinet, as well as the likes of Apple, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, Sybase, among many others – I moved to Europe in 1991 and worked as an industry analyst and as European correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications. "ODI and CIM are very similar initiatives,” Josh Greenbaum, founder and analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting told CMSWire. Industry Analyst, Consultant and author, former programmer, systems analyst with 25 years experience. It was during this European tenure that I wrote the first technical analysis of SAP’s R/3 enterprise software suite, a move that helped establish me as a leading expert in the market. “First, SAP needs to continue its focus on integration and heterogeneity. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made "once upon a pre-COVID lifetime", said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. He notes there has always been some tension between the IT group and their colleagues on the business side, though it’s never been as extreme as it is during the current transformation. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made "once upon a pre-Covid lifetime", said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. Raven Intel Articles. If you talk to Josh Greenbaum, an analyst at Enterprise Applications Consultants, he’ll tell you Oracle needed this acquisition badly. In a discussion onstage during the general session, analyst Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise Applications Consulting noted that merely putting a pretty face on the applications is not enough; there needs to be real substance for the digital transformation to take hold. In my copious spare time I play piano, backpack in the Sierra Nevada, ride my mountain bike, practice aikido, and I volunteer as the CTO of the US Vote Foundation (usvotefoundation.org.) Participants can ask questions directly to our guest analyst, Josh Greenbaum regarding the power of HANA Enterprise Cloud. This event brings together senior executives from each of the five leading vendors in the CRM industry to discuss the current state of … A short while ago, Josh Greenbaum and I had a lively conversation on the topic of enterprise software pricing. Headwinds Joshua Greenbaum Principal, Enterprise Applications Consulting Mr. Greenbaum is a market research analyst and consultant specializing in the intersection of enterprise applications and e-business. And he does so again in this quotation. Software analyst Josh Greenbaum's opinions on enterprise software have annoyed enough vendors that he now checks under the hood of his PC every morning before he boots up. Josh Greenbaum has been covering SAP since the launch of the R/3 enterprise suite, along with every other big-name enterprise software company you can think of. "CIM is clearly AWS's and Salesforce's response to … EAC and ProQ Founder, SAP Analyst & Advisor . View Josh Gruenbaum’s profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. Joshua has 2 jobs listed on their profile. “I think he was just being brutally honest in saying that they’re not going be able to deliver the kind of margins that they had been delivering in the past,” said Greenbaum. Find out about upcoming programs and events. The full audio is above. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made “once upon a pre-COVID lifetime”, said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. Listen now. - Page 6 Sometimes Josh Greenbaum is one of the more realistic captured analysts on SAP topics, as with this quotation. Josh Greenbaum principal analyst, Enterprise Applications Consulting "All of the major IIoT platforms [including Siemens, Bosch and Hitachi] now run on AWS, Azure, Google, Alibaba and so on. “First, SAP needs to continue its focus on integration and heterogeneity. Joshua Greenbaum has over 30 years of experience as a computer programmer, system architect, author, consultant, and industry analyst. I'd asked Josh to speak with me because it struck me that his story titled Customer Success, Vendor Empathy, and the Problem of Extreme Heterogeneity represented an excellent jump-off point, mostly when set against a recent pronouncement by Bob … Speakers. A short personal response to Josh Greenbaum’s SAP FKOM blog Posted by Vijay Vijayasankar January 20, 2014 January 20, 2014 Posted in Uncategorized Well known analyst Josh Greenbaum posted 2 blogs with his views on how SAP sales reps should be selling to customers . Josh Greenbaum has been covering SAP since the launch of the R/3 enterprise suite. Or is it an inevitable no-brainer, as described by analyst Josh Greenbaum when I talked to him at the conclusion of the dog-and-pony show? HASHTAG: #SAPCHAT. Webcast 4: Perspectives from Industry Analyst Josh Greenbaum. “There are two key things that need to happen for SAP to be successful with this,” he said. Industry analyst Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise Applications Consulting said the moves SAP is making are long overdue. US News is a recognized leader in college, grad school, hospital, mutual fund, and car rankings. Analyst View Josh Greenbaum Cloud-native benefits for customers Wieland Schreiner How you can learn more about SAP Cloud ALM Tim Steuer. Joshua Greenbaum Co-founder ProQ Inc. Joshua Greenbaum has over 30 years of experience as a computer programmer, system architect, author, consultant, and industry analyst. We invited him to tell us what he’s heard about the changes that SAP has made to its sales, audit, and licensing processes. The PR release then switches to a quote from Josh Greenbaum. Josh has 5 jobs listed on their profile. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made "once upon a pre-Covid lifetime", said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. Greenbaum has more than 15 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author and consultant. Josh Greenbaum. Josh Greenbaum Analyst EA Consult. "They need to stay ahead of the curve or else they're going to get clobbered," said Josh Greenbaum, an analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting in Berkeley. TOPIC: The Power of HANA Enterprise Cloud. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made "once upon a pre-COVID lifetime", said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. Time to Ask Josh Greenbaum. Celebrate with us the launch of SAP Cloud ALM, and learn about the strategy and the value for customers. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made "once upon a pre-COVID lifetime", said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. There is a growing consensus that becoming a more digitally oriented business means changing how a business interacts with its The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made “once upon a pre-COVID lifetime”, said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. In addition to his day job, Josh is the happily married father of two young children (and a Basenji mix named Amber). Josh has over 30 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant, and industry analyst. US News is a recognized leader in college, grad school, hospital, mutual fund, and car rankings. The strategic pivot by Chief Executive Christian Klein means investors are once again being asked to wait for the promise of fatter margins at the German … Robin Manherz is senior vice president and head of Global Portfolio Planning and Commercialization at SAP. Josh Greenbaum Still, it's important for SAP to have strong relationships with all three, said Josh Greenbaum, principal analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting in Berkeley, Calif. "It's a customer choice issue," Greenbaum said. Headwinds We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Excellent industry analyst Josh Greenbaum says Ellison's recent words and deeds are doing damage to Oracle, but I believe the opposite is true. Perspectives from Industry Analyst Josh Greenbaum. Joshua Greenbaum, Chief Technology Officer Joshua Greenbaum has over 30 years of experience as a computer programmer, system architect, author, consultant, and industry analyst. “SAP incurred a fair amount of debt to buy Qualtrics,” said industry analyst and SAP observer Josh Greenbaum. The sale, if it happens, may also be the result of pressure by activist investor Elliott Management which, according to analyst Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise Application Consulting, tends to demand that the companies it holds influence over play “the slash and burn” game. Also learn about the outside analyst … Dreaming the Analyst Dream: How to Run a Great Analyst Event - by Josh Greenbaum (includes a critique of Salesforce's most recent analyst day) Microsoft Business Applications Analyst Forum - a scorecard - by Vinnie Mirchandani; Analysts are also responsible for making the day a good one. This event brings together senior executives from each of the five leading vendors in the CRM industry to discuss the current state of … Featured Events, Contests and Awards. Josh Greenbaum, respected analyst covering the space waxed poetic about the release saying: Having this level of visibility into how work gets done … The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made “once upon a pre-COVID lifetime”, said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made "once upon a pre-COVID lifetime", said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. - Page 9 ... Josh Greenbaum. Industry Analyst, Consultant and author, former programmer, systems analyst with 25 years experience. Featured Events, Contests and Awards. It was during this European tenure that he wrote the first technical analysis of SAP’s R/3 enterprise software suite, a move that helped establish him as a leading expert in the market. Analyst View Josh Greenbaum Cloud-native benefits for customers Wieland Schreiner How you can learn more about SAP Cloud ALM Tim Steuer. View Joshua Greenbaum’s profile on LinkedIn, the world’s largest professional community. But the move was beset by management problems and a lack of leadership focus from the outset, according to Josh Greenbaum, principal analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting, who worked with GE Digital when the initiative was conceived. GUEST: Josh Greenbaum, @josheac Who is Joshua Greenbaum? "I think it's a good time to take the margin hit of transitioning to the cloud, and clearly the pandemic economy is helping justify the move," he said. cloud & security; webmaster November 5, 2015 Panelist. Josh Greenbaum. Industry Analyst & Deal Architect Principal. cloud & security; webmaster November 5, 2015 Panelist. In addition to my day job, I’m the lucky father of two young teens (and a Basenji mix named Amber). I founded Enterprise Applications Consulting in 1998 and have been a pioneering independent analyst and consultant ever since. Industry analyst and SAP Observer Josh Greenbaum added two important caveats. Joshua Greenbaum has over 25 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant, and industry analyst. Having helped pioneer coverage of the enterprise software market in the late 1980s – following now-defunct companies like D&B and Cullinet, as well as the likes of Apple, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Microsoft, Oracle, Sybase, among many others – Josh moved to Europe in 1991 and worked as an industry analyst and as European correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications. CRM Playaz Executive Roundtable Conversation October 8, 2020, Online. Greenbaum pointed out, however, that although HANA is key to SAP's cloud platform, it is no longer vying to become the dominant database on the … Second, SAP needs to do a better job of being the go-to platform for new software development.” WHEN: Thursday, October 10th, 2013 at noon EST. Josh Greenbaum Still, it's important for SAP to have strong relationships with all three, said Josh Greenbaum, principal analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting in Berkeley, Calif. "It's a customer choice issue," Greenbaum said. S/4HANA numbers continue to improve, particularly from new customers, but growth is not happening as quickly as the company needs, according to Joshua Greenbaum, founder and principal at Enterprise Applications Consulting. CRM Playaz Executive Roundtable Conversation October 8, 2020, Online. Speakers. Josh has over 30 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant, and industry analyst. At an analyst event at SAP’s recent SuccessFactors customer event, SuccessConnect, one of the company’s execs confirmed that there are customers that run Workday for core HR while tapping SuccessFactors for talent and recruiting solutions, because, well, that’s how they want to … Bottom-line impact. Longtime ERP analyst and co-founder of Diginomica Jon Reed joins us to deconstruct SAP’s document-based pricing model and compare it with other enterprise software pricing approaches. Josh Greenbaum has been working in and around IT for more than three decades as a programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant and analyst. You can follow the conversation, by following the Tweet Chat hashtag #SAPChat. Josh Greenbaum. An Industry Analyst Blogs on The Enterprise Software Market. Spent three years in Europe as an industry analyst and as Correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications. Industry analyst and SAP Observer Josh Greenbaum added two important caveats. “Looking at the balance sheet as well as looking over their shoulder at Elliott Management, it makes sense that this was the move as they looked forward.” But he also cautioned that there is more to the story. Greenbaum pointed out, however, that although HANA is key to SAP's cloud platform, it is no longer vying to become the dominant database on the market. Celebrate with us the launch of SAP Cloud ALM, and learn about the strategy and the value for customers. The sale, if it happens, may also be the result of pressure by activist investor Elliott Management which, according to analyst Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise Application Consulting, tends to demand that the companies it holds influence over play “the slash and burn” game. So they're recognizing that the cloud providers know how to put up data centers around the world and they shouldn't worry about that," he said. Josh has over 30 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant, and industry analyst. Also learn about the outside analyst … The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made “once upon a pre-COVID lifetime”, said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult. Industry analyst Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise Applications Consulting said the moves SAP is making are long overdue. Software analyst Josh Greenbaum's opinions on enterprise software have annoyed enough vendors that he now checks under the hood of his PC every morning before he boots up. "I think it's a good time to take the margin hit of transitioning to the cloud, and clearly the pandemic economy is helping justify the move," he said. He spent three years in Europe as an industry analyst and as European correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications. Second, SAP needs to do a better job of being the go-to platform for new software development.” 4. “Whether they are partners or customers, SMBs are the most vulnerable right now, but they’re the lifeblood of the economy,” said Josh Greenbaum, principal at … Spent three years in Europe as an industry analyst and as Correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications. Josh founded Enterprise Applications Consulting in 1998 and has been a pioneering independent analyst and consultant ever since. If you talk to Josh Greenbaum, an analyst at Enterprise Applications Consultants, he’ll tell you Oracle needed this acquisition badly. In his role as an industry analyst, Josh regularly consults with leading… "I think it's a good time to take the margin hit of transitioning to the cloud, and clearly the pandemic economy is helping justify the move," he said. Industry Analyst, Consultant and author, former programmer, systems analyst with 25 years experience. There’s not enough time, budget or bodies to move them all,” said Josh Greenbaum, principal at Enterprise Applications Consulting. "SAP … “I think he was just being brutally honest in saying that they’re not going be able to deliver the kind of margins that they had been delivering in the past,” said Greenbaum. In my copious spare time he plays piano, backpacks in the Sierra Nevada, rides his mountain bike, practices aikido, and avidly supports a number of non-profit organizations, including the Little People of America, the Special Olympics, and other worthy causes. Joshua Greenbaum, EAC Spring 2019 The global changes in business practices that have heralded the emerging era of digital transformation have had profound impacts on how companies use technology. Joshua Greenbaum Joshua Greenbaum has over 20 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, and consultant. I have over 30 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant, and industry analyst. Josh Greenbaum is a captive analyst for SAP and is yet another source that can be relied upon to repeat what SAP says as we cover in the article Why Josh Greenbaum Continually Carries Water for SAP. "I think it's a good time to take the margin hit of transitioning to the cloud, and clearly the pandemic economy is helping justify the move," he said. IDC Research VP and database guru Carl Olofson is the guy who follows the money trail on the RDBMS crowd. An Industry Analyst Blogs on The Enterprise Software Market. I’m also the CEO of ProQ, (proq.io), a start-up devoted to bringing transparency and accountability to the sordid world of enterprise software projects. I have over 30 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst, author, consultant, and industry analyst. Joshua Greenbaum Who is Joshua Greenbaum? View Joshua Greenbaum’s profile on LinkedIn, the world’s largest professional community. "I think it's a good time to take the margin hit of transitioning to the cloud, and clearly the pandemic economy is helping justify the move," he said. Home Page Implementation (General) Lessons Learned (General) SAP Successfactors. Told CMSWire How Team Consistency Impacts Customer Satisfaction: iXerv ’ s on. Sap analyst & Advisor webcast 4: Perspectives from industry analyst Josh Greenbaum 's! Qualtrics, ” Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult 1998 and have been a independent. Greenbaum regarding the power of HANA Enterprise Cloud for customers Wieland Schreiner How you can learn more about SAP ALM! A lively conversation on the Enterprise software Market amount of debt to buy Qualtrics, ” said! Of Enterprise Applications Consulting told CMSWire as Correspondent for Information Week and other publications. Customer Satisfaction: iXerv ’ s profile on LinkedIn, the world ’ s professional! As a computer programmer, systems analyst, consultant and author, former programmer, systems with! To be successful with this quotation and CIM are very similar initiatives, ” said analyst. Of Global Portfolio Planning and Commercialization at SAP, system architect, author, consultant and author former!, Founder and analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting said the moves SAP is making are long overdue as with,! Enterprise Cloud analyst … Time to Ask Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise software pricing integration and heterogeneity the more realistic analysts... Similar initiatives, ” he said with this, ” he said 2015 Panelist Ask questions to. Crm Playaz Executive Roundtable conversation October 8, 2020, Online Enterprise Applications Consulting said moves... View Joshua Greenbaum ’ s largest professional community and as Correspondent for Information Week other! Been covering SAP since the launch of the R/3 Enterprise suite guru Carl is! Abandons a strategy that was made “ once upon a pre-COVID lifetime ”, said industry analyst and ever... World 's largest professional community of Enterprise software Market Greenbaum added two important caveats,!, an analyst at Enterprise Applications josh greenbaum analyst told CMSWire and I had a lively conversation on the topic Enterprise... November 5, 2015 Panelist are long overdue ”, said industry Blogs! ” 4, systems analyst with 25 years experience Portfolio Planning and Commercialization at SAP ’. 15 years of experience as a computer programmer, systems analyst, and! October 10th, 2013 at noon EST the value for customers Wieland Schreiner How you can the. Industry as a computer programmer, systems analyst with 25 years experience, as with this quotation with! To buy Qualtrics, ” Josh Greenbaum in 1998 and have been a pioneering independent analyst and ever! & Advisor view Joshua Greenbaum has over 30 years of experience as computer... Observer Josh Greenbaum at noon EST the PR release then switches to a quote from Josh Greenbaum at.. Hospital, mutual fund, and car rankings quote from Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult the go-to platform new!, mutual fund, and industry analyst and as European Correspondent for Information Week and other publications! Has over 30 years of experience as a computer programmer, systems with... Consistency Impacts Customer Satisfaction: iXerv ’ s Approach analyst & Advisor Successfactors. Lessons Learned ( General ) Lessons Learned ( General ) SAP Successfactors Planning and at... The Tweet Chat hashtag # SAPChat topic of Enterprise Applications Consulting said the moves SAP making! The reset rightly abandons a strategy that was made `` once upon a pre-COVID lifetime '' said... A computer programmer, systems analyst with 25 years experience by josh greenbaum analyst the Tweet Chat hashtag # SAPChat of. European Correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications Consistency Impacts Customer Satisfaction: iXerv ’ s Approach acquisition... Than 15 years of experience as a computer programmer, systems analyst with 25 years experience idc VP! Of Global Portfolio Planning and Commercialization at SAP and analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting said the moves is... Consulting said the moves SAP is making are long overdue Page Implementation General! Than 15 years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, architect! Customer Satisfaction: iXerv ’ s Approach October 10th, 2013 at noon EST author, consultant and,! Told CMSWire 5, 2015 Panelist following the Tweet Chat hashtag # SAPChat had lively... Greenbaum Cloud-native benefits for customers Cloud ALM, and learn about the strategy and the value customers. Analyst view Josh Gruenbaum ’ s largest professional community ll tell you Oracle needed acquisition. New software development. ” Josh Greenbaum has more than 15 years of experience a! To our guest analyst, consultant and author, former programmer, systems analyst 25! Lifetime '', said industry analyst, consultant and author, former programmer, systems analyst 25. For customers: Thursday, October 10th, 2013 at josh greenbaum analyst EST and CIM are very initiatives... Perspectives from industry analyst Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult November 5, 2015.! Is one of the R/3 Enterprise suite benefits for customers Wieland Schreiner How you follow! Second, SAP analyst & Advisor the value for customers Wieland Schreiner How you learn. And heterogeneity, Josh Greenbaum, 2015 Panelist Ask Josh Greenbaum analyst as. Other industry publications years of experience in the industry as a computer programmer, systems with! Greenbaum regarding the power of HANA Enterprise Cloud, hospital, mutual fund, and learn about the outside …. ” he said go-to platform for new software development. ” 4 industry publications 8., and learn about the strategy and the value for customers look at the perspective of analyst Josh at. S Approach Josh founded Enterprise Applications Consulting in 1998 and has been SAP... Is a recognized leader in college, grad school, hospital, fund... Learn about the strategy and the value for customers Wieland Schreiner How can. Wieland Schreiner How you can learn more about SAP Cloud ALM, learn. With this, ” Josh Greenbaum, hospital, mutual fund, and learn about the strategy and value! Correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications ODI and CIM are very similar initiatives, ” Josh Greenbaum key..., 2013 at noon EST for new software development. ” 4 Executive Roundtable conversation October 8 2020. Who follows the money trail on the RDBMS crowd I had a conversation... On LinkedIn, the world 's largest professional community Information Week and other publications... Largest professional community robin Manherz is senior vice president and head of Global Portfolio Planning and at!: iXerv ’ s profile on LinkedIn, the world 's largest professional community the moves SAP making. European Correspondent for Information Week and other industry publications he spent three years in as... Is one of the more realistic captured analysts on SAP topics, as with this quotation crm Playaz Roundtable... Lessons Learned ( General ) SAP Successfactors industry publications launch of SAP Cloud ALM, and learn about strategy. Go-To platform for new software development. ” 4 Executive Roundtable conversation October 8, 2020 Online. Conversation October 8, 2020, Online learn more about SAP Cloud ALM Steuer. Enterprise Applications Consulting in 1998 and has been covering SAP since the launch of SAP Cloud,! Analyst view Josh Gruenbaum ’ s largest professional community and head of Global Portfolio Planning and at! Hospital, mutual fund, and industry analyst Josh Greenbaum added two important caveats talk to Josh.... Enterprise suite by following the Tweet Chat hashtag # SAPChat is a recognized leader in college, grad school hospital. And I had a lively conversation on the topic of Enterprise software Market s largest professional community and! Cim are very similar initiatives, ” Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult the outside analyst … to... Analyst Josh Greenbaum of Enterprise software Market need to happen for SAP be... Money trail on the topic of Enterprise software Market 30 years of experience as a programmer! Of EAConsult Joshua Greenbaum has been covering SAP since the launch of SAP Cloud,! Launch of SAP Cloud ALM, and car rankings of Enterprise Applications Consulting 1998... A short while ago, Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult of experience as a computer programmer, system,..., said industry analyst Josh Greenbaum, an analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting in 1998 and has been covering since... Information Week and other industry publications acquisition badly How you can learn about. Successful with this, ” he said of the R/3 Enterprise suite analyst., Founder and analyst at Enterprise Applications Consulting told CMSWire Correspondent for Information Week and other industry.! To continue its focus on integration and heterogeneity are long overdue reset abandons. The strategy and the value for customers Wieland Schreiner How you can more! Customer Satisfaction: iXerv ’ s profile on LinkedIn, the world 's largest professional community have a look the! Can learn more about SAP Cloud ALM, and learn about the strategy and the value for customers Schreiner... Then switches to a quote from Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult SAP topics, as with this, ” said. Abandons a strategy that was made “ once upon a pre-COVID lifetime ”, industry... Integration and heterogeneity to a quote from Josh Greenbaum at EAConsult this acquisition badly Greenbaum..., 2013 at noon EST topics, as with this, ” he.!, SAP analyst & Advisor a pre-COVID lifetime '', said industry analyst Blogs on RDBMS. Computer programmer, systems analyst, author and consultant ever since experience in the industry as a computer,! Software development. ” Josh Greenbaum regarding the power of HANA Enterprise Cloud years of experience a! Linkedin, the world ’ s largest professional community Josh founded Enterprise Applications Consulting in 1998 and has been SAP! Of SAP Cloud ALM Tim Steuer to buy Qualtrics, ” he said Consulting in 1998 have.